Herd Management

What Fitness % Should You Cull At?

Community testing points to a working threshold of 50%: cull adults below it, be stricter with young animals (under 40%), and leave fit young males alone to mature. Females are usually only worth taking in their final year. No official threshold has been published.

The working threshold table

AgeFitnessAction
YoungUnder 40%Cull — they drag the group down longest
Young40% and aboveLeave — this is your future trophy
AdultUnder 50%Cull
Adult50% and aboveLeave or observe
Final yearAnyHarvest — check the trophy first
FemaleNot final yearLeave

Rule-led guidance, not genetic prediction. These numbers are community-tested, not published by Nine Rocks.

The region matters more than the number

Populations are managed by region, not by the single group in front of you. Each region has its own ceiling — a 45% animal may be worth keeping where the region tops out at “vulnerable”, and worth culling where it can reach “healthy”. Check the group's status label before you pull the trigger.

Habitat work raises that ceiling. Removing pollution and clearing invasive species has the biggest effect; feeders are the smallest lever.

The four-step loop

  1. Pick one species in one region and stay there until it stabilises.
  2. Scan every group of that species in the region, not just the first one you find.
  3. Take the single lowest-fitness animal, then sleep three days (one year).
  4. Repeat, and fix pollution or invasive-species sites early so the ceiling rises.

What is still unverified

  • The exact inheritance maths — how much of a parent's fitness passes on.
  • Whether females pass fitness at the same rate as males.
  • Spawn formulas and how many new animals appear per year.
  • Whether the 50% figure holds on every difficulty and every species.

Use the Culling Decision Assistant to record what you actually saw; it returns Keep / Cull Candidate / Observe First and shows when a rule is unverified. Last verified: 2026-10-17 · game version 1.0

FAQ

FAQ

Common questions about this topic.

Is the 50% threshold official?

No. Nine Rocks has not published culling numbers; 50% is a community-tested working rule.

Should I shoot females?

Usually only in their final year. They influence the group, but less than males, and removing them early slows growth.

Do star ratings matter when culling?

Stars show the current trophy, not potential. A one-star young male with high fitness is exactly what you keep.

What should I fix first in a region?

Pollution and invasive species — official patch notes say they directly affect fitness and population potential. Feeders are the smallest effect.